Shiv Sena Case Supreme Court : Sanjay Raut Predicts Verdict in February | Kapil Sibal vs Dhruv Mehta Arguments, WhatsApp Notice, Gogawale Whip Issue and Next Hearing on 25 November

The battle over “whose Shiv Sena is it?” is nearing its final stage in the Supreme Court. Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut has predicted that the question will be decided in February. Meanwhile, senior counsel Kapil Sibal, appearing for the Thackeray side, argued that “Eknath Shinde cannot be the Shiv Sena“, while the Shinde side, through senior counsel Dhruv Mehta, attacked the notice and evidence used against its MLAs. The next hearing is on 25 November.

WhatsApp Channel Join Now
Telegram Group Join Now
Instagram Group Join Now
YouTube Channel Subscribe

Shiv Sena Case at a Glance

DetailInformation
CourtSupreme Court of India
IssueDisqualification of MLAs and the question of the real Shiv Sena
Thackeray side counselKapil Sibal
Shinde side counselDhruv Mehta
Raut’s predictionDecision in February
Next hearing25 November 2026

What Sanjay Raut Said

Raut predicted that the Shiv Sena question would be decided in February. The report presents this as his prediction (भाकीत), made before the 25 November hearing, and says it created a stir in political circles. It is not a court schedule.

Shiv Sena Case: Arguments
Shiv Sena Case: Arguments (Source: Election Guru research)

Kapil Sibal’s Arguments for the Thackeray Side

  • “एकनाथ शिंदे म्हणजे शिवसेना होऊ शकत नाही” (Eknath Shinde cannot be the Shiv Sena)
  • Bharat Gogawale‘s appointment as whip was wrong and was not made by the political party
  • Since February 2023 Shinde has had a political party of his own; before that, the Thackeray side was the party (“म्हणजे त्यापूर्वी आम्ही पक्ष होतो ना”)
  • Shinde represented only the legislature party, not the political party

Dhruv Mehta’s Arguments for the Shinde Side

On 17 November, the Shinde camp raised the 21 June 2022 meeting called by the then undivided Shiv Sena and the WhatsApp message used to call it. Its arguments, as reported, were:

  • The meeting had no specific agenda
  • The notice was sent by WhatsApp
  • The meeting was at 12:30 pm and the message reached Shinde at 12:31 pm
  • The Thackeray whip lacked clarity, and the evidence was only a WhatsApp screenshot
  • Yogesh Kadam, Uday Samant, Deepak Kesarkar, Dada Bhuse and Deepak Lande signed after the meeting, yet disqualification petitions were filed against them
  • Disqualification must be proved on evidence, and the Speaker needs to hold an internal inquiry

Timeline of the Shiv Sena Split Case

DateDevelopment
June 2022Eknath Shinde and MLAs rebel; MVA government falls
30 June 2022Shinde becomes Chief Minister with BJP support
February 2023Election Commission gives Shiv Sena name and bow-and-arrow symbol to Shinde faction
May 2023Supreme Court Constitution Bench verdict; asks Speaker to decide disqualification
January 2024Speaker Rahul Narwekar rules Shinde faction is the real Shiv Sena
17 November 2026Shinde side argues on WhatsApp notice and evidence
20 November 2026Sibal argues for Thackeray side
25 November 2026Next hearing

Also Read: Eknath Shinde’s Kartiki Ekadashi Mahapuja 2026 in Pandharpur

Why the WhatsApp Notice Matters

Disqualification under the anti-defection law depends on whether MLAs defied a valid party direction. If the notice for the 21 June 2022 meeting was not properly served, or the whip was not clear, the Shinde side argues there can be no defiance. The Thackeray side argues that Shinde’s group was never the political party and that its whip appointment itself was invalid.

What Is at Stake

  • Name and symbol: the “Shiv Sena” name and bow-and-arrow symbol
  • Disqualification of MLAs who went with Shinde in 2022
  • Political legitimacy ahead of civic and local elections
  • The broader interpretation of the anti-defection law and Speaker’s powers

Shinde’s Reaction

Asked about the hearing in Pandharpur on Kartiki Ekadashi, Eknath Shinde said: “सर्वकाही पांडुरंगाच्या कृपेने मनासारखं होईल” (By Pandurang’s grace, everything will happen as desired).

Also Read: Uddhav Thackeray Biography

Election Guru Analysis

The arguments show that the case now turns on technical evidence (a WhatsApp notice, a one-minute gap, a screenshot) as much as on the big question of who represents the party. Raut’s February forecast keeps the Thackeray base energised, but only the court will set the date. Whatever the verdict, it will shape Maharashtra politics and the use of the anti-defection law across India.

Watch: Shiv Sena Case Video

Shiv Sena Case (Short) Video Source : YouTube

For the detailed background, watch the full Election Guru video below.

Election Guru Full Video Source : YouTube

Shiv Sena Case FAQ

When will the Shiv Sena case verdict come?

Sanjay Raut has predicted a decision in February; the court has not announced a verdict date.

When is the next hearing?

The next Supreme Court hearing is on 25 November 2026.

What did Kapil Sibal argue?

He argued that Eknath Shinde cannot be the Shiv Sena and that Bharat Gogawale’s appointment as whip was wrong.

What did the Shinde side argue?

Dhruv Mehta argued that the 21 June 2022 WhatsApp notice reached Shinde a minute after the meeting time and that the evidence was only a screenshot.

Who got the Shiv Sena symbol?

The Election Commission gave the Shiv Sena name and bow-and-arrow symbol to the Shinde faction in February 2023.

What did Eknath Shinde say about the case?

He said everything will happen as desired by Pandurang’s grace.

Leave a Comment